• We are now running on a new, and hopefully much-improved, server. In addition we are also on new forum software. Any move entails a lot of technical details and I suspect we will encounter a few issues as the new server goes live. Please be patient with us. It will be worth it! :) Please help by posting all issues here.
  • The forum will be down for about an hour this weekend for maintenance. I apologize for the inconvenience.
  • If you are having trouble seeing the forum then you may need to clear your browser's DNS cache. Click here for instructions on how to do that
  • Please review the Forum Rules frequently as we are constantly trying to improve the forum for our members and visitors.

List Your Open Carry Experiences Here

DrTodd

Michigan Moderator
Joined
Jun 20, 2008
Messages
3,272
Location
Hudsonville , Michigan, USA
Ferret, hows about sending some emails up the chain of command at 5/3, emphisizing it was HIM pushing to close your accounts and is this the way customers are treated, if the manager doesnt like something.

Dear _____:

Thank you for using Fifth Third. In response to recent inquiry, the safety of our customers is important to 5/3 and to limit the anxiety and concerns of the majority of our customers we have chosen to not allow the carrying of concealed weapons. We would like to take this opportunity to thank you for your business and look forward to serving you in the future. If you require any further assistance, please email us 24 hours a day or contact a Customer Service Professional at 1-800-972-3030, Monday through Friday between 7:00 AM and 12:00 AM, ET, Saturday or Sunday from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM, ET. At Fifth Third Bank, We're "Working Hard To Be The Only Bank You'll Ever Need. ®"
Randy R
Fifth Third Internet Banking


This mentions "concealed firearms", pretty sure OC firearms are also prohibited.
 
Last edited:

Shadow Bear

Michigan Moderator
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
1,004
Location
Grand Rapids
Ferret, hows about sending some emails up the chain of command at 5/3, emphisizing it was HIM pushing to close your accounts and is this the way customers are treated, if the manager doesnt like something.

This assumes that there any humans in positions of authority at 5/3, which, from personal experience, there are not.

Every one is an arrogant blowhole, and I curse them to the seventh generation. /rant off

OT- Steel Magnolia OCed Cascade Wallymart to pick up a few neccesities. Was asked by one gentleman if she had enough ammunition (three full mags plus 1 in the pipe), to which she replied 'Just a full combat load'. Not sure that was exactly the right thing to say:uhoh: (obviously I'm rubbing off on her, after 32 years....), but I'm darn proud of her.

Fellow mentioned that he has a Ruger Super Redhawk, but he had never felt the need to carry it. She replied that he didn't have a stalker, either. He closed with compliments to her about being brave, which she is. (where's the little smiley for getting a little mushy?:):))

When the SHTF, she's the one I want backing me up!:D
 

Orion

Regular Member
Joined
May 1, 2011
Messages
108
Location
Detroit
-snip-Well so far today I OC'd at the Secretary of State's office to renew license plates for 3 vehicles... forgot to bring along the proof of insurance and didn't even realize it until I was back home more than a couple of hundred dollars poorer but with new tags. Did something change about proof of insurance that I missed?-snip-

Nowadays if you have had insurance consecutively they place a pin number at the bottom of your registration, which allows you to renew without bringing your documents in.
 
B

Bikenut

Guest
-snip-Well so far today I OC'd at the Secretary of State's office to renew license plates for 3 vehicles... forgot to bring along the proof of insurance and didn't even realize it until I was back home more than a couple of hundred dollars poorer but with new tags. Did something change about proof of insurance that I missed?-snip-

Nowadays if you have had insurance consecutively they place a pin number at the bottom of your registration, which allows you to renew without bringing your documents in.
Aha! Thanky kindly!:D
 

cmdr_iceman71

Regular Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2010
Messages
409
Location
Detroit, Michigan, USA
OCed last night at Olive Garden in Warren. Today, Boost Mobile and Glory Foods in Highland Park. No problems, no issues.

Good on you Ferret for standing upon principle and removing your funds. Many talk the talk but far fewer actually walk the walk.
 

Get2DahChopper

Regular Member
Joined
Dec 18, 2010
Messages
65
Location
Warren. Michigan
Just an idea here:

Open carried to 5/3 bank again yesterday. Ended up withdrawing all my funds and closing my accounts. Here's what happened:

Went in, stood in line with Ms. Ferret for about 10 minutes, my business was conducted, and as I was about to leave, the manager came up and the following ensued as best as I can recall:

Him: "I don't want to argue the *amendment* with you, but you will end up getting yourself in trouble for bringing that in here."
Me: "No, I wont. It's perfectly legal with a concealed pistol license."
Him: "Here's the problem right here, if customers are complaining... You have to watch what you say too. In here while you're carrying." (I had thanked Ms. Ferret for handing me water and had talked about books we're reading and politics (especially voter suppression))
Me: "Good thing I am."
Him: "'Cause if these guys over here are hitting a button then you could get in trouble for attempted robbery at that point." (What the hell?)
Me: "No, I can't because I'm not attempting to rob you, so I can't get in trouble for attempted robbery. And, if you guys want to keep hassling me every time I come in, I'll take all my funds and go to a different bank because it's starting to get on my nerves."
Him: "Really?" (sees his opportunity to never see me again, oops. at least banks are a dime a dozen.)

At this point, the customer service rep, who has been totally friendly this whole time, hands me my money, and I say "You have a nice day," and turn to leave.
The manager then says, "Why don't we do that." ("that" meaning close my accounts)
So we went to his office, and as he was getting my accounts closed and funds withdrawn, we talked a little more.

Him: "The only thing I would suggest is using the drive-through."
Me: "I'm not going to use the drive through just because you're afraid."
Him: "I'm not afraid."
Me: "Well obviously you are because you have an issue with my firearm."
Him: "I didn't want to come to office and wonder if I have to press charges against you."
Me: "You can't."
Him: "For trespassing I can."
Me: "You can, after you ask me to leave, if I don't leave." (which did not happen)
Him: "Right. And that's why, it's like, they came and asked me because other customers had called on you."
Me: "So? It seems to be a problem with the customers. They don't know the laws. You can teach them. You can say, 'Hey, it's fine for him to open carry in here. We don't have a problem with him, and you shouldn't either.' That's what you should tell your customers when they complain."

He didn't have a response to that one. He started talking about my accounts. Afterwards:

Him: "If I have customers and the police are involved, I have to savor the difference here. So I mean, it's not anything that's a fear thing. It's no different than us not being able to have dogs in the bank."
Me: "But you're allowed to have openly carrying customers with concealed pistol licenses in your bank. It's perfectly lawful. I can show you the attorney general opinion saying that it's lawful. If you had a customer come in with something as simple as a backpack, you wouldn't ask them to leave for that."
Him: "We can kick people out for wearing hats if we ask them to remove them."
Me: "Exactly, but you wouldn't because you're courteous to your customers, but you're not being courteous to me. And I've been a customer since I moved here a couple of years ago. Now you guys are saying, 'Hey, guess what. You can't come in here. You can't defend your life. You can't exercise your rights. You can't be a law-abiding citizen in our bank. We don't want you here. That's what you're saying to me."
Him: "No-"
Me: "Yes, that's exactly what you're saying to me!"
Him: "It's not what I'm saying."
Me: "So what are you saying?"
Him: "I don't want the gun in my bank. It's fine. You can come in anytime you want, but-
Me: "I'm not going to come in without being able to defend my life if armed robbers come through the door and start marching everyone to the back to execute us one by one. Do you understand me? So you do what you need to do right now. I need to go find another bank. Just so you know in the future, when law-abiding citizens come into your bank, the guns don't leave their holsters unless somebody's life is in danger. We're all taught very well how to handle our firearms. And it's just outrageous to me that you would treat me in such a way and act as if I'm a threat to your customers. It makes me sad that our country comes to that. "
Him: "It's the customers telling me."
Me: "Well, tell them that it's legal. If somebody complains, 'Hey, this guy over here smells,' are you going to tell that guy to leave or are you going to say, 'Hey, don't stand so close to him.'?"
Him: "It's different with a gun in a bank."
Me: "Well, I'm not waving it around. I'm not brandishing. I'm following the law, and you just have horrible business practices to be making your customers withdraw their funds and go elsewhere."
Him: "To be honest, when the cops showed up here I thought that you weren't gonna come back here."
Me: "They can't do anything. They came to my house, we had a brief conversation, and they left. There's nothing they can do. I'm following the law."
Him: "I didn't even know about it until they came after they filed a report to find out."
Me: "A lot of people call the cops to scare others from carrying and defending their lives, and I'm not going to stop just because a cop had a conversation with me. I'm not going to be caught defenseless one day when my life is in danger. I'm a responsible, law-abiding citizen and I'm just not going to have any of it."
Him: "Here's the thing, I probably have more guns than you do."
Me: "Probably."
Him: "But I have to watch out for what everyone else wants. That's why we can't have dogs in the bank anymore."
Me: "Why?"
Him: "'Cause someone complained. They were complaining."
Ms. Ferret: "Even seeing eye dogs?"
Him: "Seeing eye dogs can come, but they have to make everyone aware a dog is coming in. It's ridiculous."
Me: "It just makes me upset that this is a country where someone complains about somebody doing something that is perfectly lawful and action is taken against them because of a complaint from a citizen who doesn't know the law. I've studied the law day and night for three months now, and I know what my rights are. They don't. And when they come to you and complain about it, if they ever do it again, I really hope you would just say, 'You know what? That's legal,' but obviously it will be with another open carrier and not with me."

He didn't have a response here either.

After I got my money, he kept wanting to suddenly talk about his brother in law enforcement and what guns he has bought from him. I figured, he's either trying to not seem like a bad guy, or he's trying to stall me until the cops arrive. Either way, I bid him a good day and left. No LEO encounter followed.

I am pretty disgusted with the whole situation. Can anyone reccommend an OC friendly bank in the Walker/Standale area?

After this encounter, I went to carry in Meijer to get groceries. No problems, as it should have been 300 feet away in the bank.

Carry on.



P.S. I'm down for a Walker event, I think DrTodd and I can organize something.



You know what would be neat? If we could find a dozen or so CPL/OCers in the area to go into that branch on a preselected day (on a Friday/Sat or Monday) their busiest days and all line up one by one & open up accounts with the very minimum allowed usually $5 for savings. If nothing is said then come back a couple of times all together and stand in line to make a small deposit/with drawl from your accounts. If something is said then walk out to the public sidewalk and form a picket line.

This would be done with the local TV stations being given plenty of notice (a few hours) in advance so this manager can go on the air and explain why peoples feelings trump peoples rights. I know it's a little in your face, but without media attention they will never budge! Look at Starbucks they fought us at first, but once they agreed to follow state law they saw their profits go up by 10%. So I guess Starbucks customers are just braver than 5/3rd Bank customers? I doubt that.:confused:
 
Last edited:

FerretMI

Regular Member
Joined
May 6, 2011
Messages
69
Location
Holland
Thank you all for your kind words. It's great to be supported by my fellow open carriers.

I open carried today to pay rent and mail a package. No issues whatsoever.
 

DanM

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2008
Messages
1,928
Location
West Bloomfield, Michigan, USA
OC'd at 12 Oaks Mall in Novi around lunchtime with Rob (Robbiex11b) and Brandon. Visited "steve jaye", another OC'er who was working in the mall. His co-worker is also an OC'er. On our way around the mall on an errand, passed two security. No issues. Then, ate lunch and had to leave and go back to work. No issues during the time I was there.

After work, I visited Target and Costco to check on things after Rob's recent post:
So, today went out to do some shopping at Target in Commerce [and got kicked out by a manager]. . . .
And then I went to Costco in Commerce Township [and got kicked out].

I spent 20 minutes in Target. First thing, I went to customer service and asked about recycling some bottles I had. They noticed. I then browsed, picked up some items I needed, paid, and left. No issues.

On to Costco. Spent about 40 minutes there. Gathered information from Customer Service as a prospective "new member", walked and browsed the whole store (can't buy, though, until you're a member), and ate at the food court. No issues.

Earlier in the day, at the mall, Rob had some speculation as to the way he was treated. Rob, what do you think?
 
Last edited:

steve jaye

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2008
Messages
34
Location
Plymouth
OC'd at 12 Oaks Mall in Novi around lunchtime with Rob (Robbiex11b) and Brandon. Visited "steve jaye", another OC'er who was working in the mall. His co-worker is also an OC'er. On our way around the mall on an errand, passed two security. No issues. Then, ate lunch and had to leave and go back to work. No issues during the time I was there.

After work, I visited Target and Costco to check on things after Rob's recent post:


I spent 20 minutes in Target. First thing, I went to customer service and asked about recycling some bottles I had. They noticed. I then browsed, picked up some items I needed, paid, and left. No issues.

On to Costco. Spent about 40 minutes there. Gathered information from Customer Service as a prospective "new member", walked and browsed the whole store (can't buy, though, until you're a member), and ate at the food court. No issues.

Earlier in the day, at the mall, Rob had some speculation as to the way he was treated. Rob, what do you think?

I was very nice to meet you guys today.
 

Rasher

Regular Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Messages
88
Location
Dearborn Heights MI, ,
Dear _____:

Thank you for using Fifth Third. In response to recent inquiry, the safety of our customers is important to 5/3 and to limit the anxiety and concerns of the majority of our customers we have chosen to not allow the carrying of concealed weapons. We would like to take this opportunity to thank you for your business and look forward to serving you in the future. If you require any further assistance, please email us 24 hours a day or contact a Customer Service Professional at 1-800-972-3030, Monday through Friday between 7:00 AM and 12:00 AM, ET, Saturday or Sunday from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM, ET. At Fifth Third Bank, We're "Working Hard To Be The Only Bank You'll Ever Need. ®"
Randy R
Fifth Third Internet Banking


This mentions "concealed firearms", pretty sure OC firearms are also prohibited.

This assumes that there any humans in positions of authority at 5/3, which, from personal experience, there are not.

Every one is an arrogant blowhole, and I curse them to the seventh generation. /rant off

OT- Steel Magnolia OCed Cascade Wallymart to pick up a few neccesities. Was asked by one gentleman if she had enough ammunition (three full mags plus 1 in the pipe), to which she replied 'Just a full combat load'. Not sure that was exactly the right thing to say:uhoh: (obviously I'm rubbing off on her, after 32 years....), but I'm darn proud of her.

Fellow mentioned that he has a Ruger Super Redhawk, but he had never felt the need to carry it. She replied that he didn't have a stalker, either. He closed with compliments to her about being brave, which she is. (where's the little smiley for getting a little mushy?:):))

When the SHTF, she's the one I want backing me up!:D


Ive had my dealings with 5/3, when the wife and I were first married, WILL NEVER GO BACK. Just hope'n MAYBE a change for the better.

OT. Oc'd Krogers in Taylor, Save a lot in Dearborn and Citgo behind BK Tele&94, not a word anywere, altho a few wide eyes and wispering at citgo.
 

Bronson

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
2,126
Location
Battle Creek, Michigan, USA
Can anyone reccommend an OC friendly bank in the Walker/Standale area?

Good on you sir, well done. Try a credit union. I belong to two and have OCed in both without any problems.

Earlier in the day, at the mall, Rob had some speculation as to the way he was treated. Rob, what do you think?

Is Rob a young man, say, in his twenties? Maybe it's just me but it sure seems that the younger looking OCers tend to get hassled more.

Bronson
 

RenegadeMarine

Regular Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
79
Location
Fraser, Michigan, USA
Maybe it's just me but it sure seems that the younger looking OCers tend to get hassled more. Bronson

I tend to disagreee with this. I am 34, but I've been told that I look like I am 25 or younger. I have been OC'ing for more than 2 years, anywhere and everywhere I go, and I have not had one negative encounter (general public or LEO's). Call me lucky, but sadly I believe it is all about how you look and how you carry yourself. It sucks but unfortunately that's what we have to deal with, until OC is more accepted in MI. Obviously there are some people that are going to make a stink regardless of how old you are or what you look like.
 

Bronson

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
2,126
Location
Battle Creek, Michigan, USA
I tend to disagreee with this. I am 34, but I've been told that I look like I am 25 or younger.

You're arguing specifics against generalities. I wrote that it seems that younger looking people tend to get hassled more. Not that younger looking people will get hassled more or that all younger looking people will get hassled or that only younger looking people will get hassled.

After reading these stories for a few years now it seems to me to trend toward younger folks get hassled more often.

Just because it hasn't happened to you doesn't negate everything I've read in the past.

Bronson
 

Robbiex11b

New member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
9
Location
Wolverine Lake, Michigan, USA
Good on you sir, well done. Try a credit union. I belong to two and have OCed in both without any problems.



Is Rob a young man, say, in his twenties? Maybe it's just me but it sure seems that the younger looking OCers tend to get hassled more.

Bronson

Yes, indeed I am "younger" than some. 28. However, I feel I dress and carry myself appropriately. At the time of the Costco incident, I had my fiance and 1 year old child with me browsing around for a few things. The manager that approached me stated that " I didn't look threatening and that he often carries but not in the store".

At any rate, I will be looking to Sams Club for a new membership. That is just what I do. I wont shop Target, wont Shop Costco, or any other anti-carry stores. There are plenty of places to purchase items without my rights being questioned.
 

Robbiex11b

New member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
9
Location
Wolverine Lake, Michigan, USA
Earlier in the day, at the mall, Rob had some speculation as to the way he was treated. Rob, what do you think?

Maybe. I just shaved my head (messed up my haircut) and maybe I looked like a mean guy. Not sure.

It was a good OC day at 12 Oaks though. As Dan stated, no issues at all. Glad to meet up with you any time again for future carries.

Rx
 

DinoX11b

New member
Joined
Nov 21, 2009
Messages
1
Location
, Michigan, USA
OC'd at 12 Oaks Mall in Novi around lunchtime with Rob (Robbiex11b) and Brandon. Visited "steve jaye", another OC'er who was working in the mall. His co-worker is also an OC'er. On our way around the mall on an errand, passed two security. No issues. Then, ate lunch and had to leave and go back to work. No issues during the time I was there.

After work, I visited Target and Costco to check on things after Rob's recent post:


I spent 20 minutes in Target. First thing, I went to customer service and asked about recycling some bottles I had. They noticed. I then browsed, picked up some items I needed, paid, and left. No issues.

On to Costco. Spent about 40 minutes there. Gathered information from Customer Service as a prospective "new member", walked and browsed the whole store (can't buy, though, until you're a member), and ate at the food court. No issues.

Earlier in the day, at the mall, Rob had some speculation as to the way he was treated. Rob, what do you think?

I am Brandon, I was the 3rd in the OC line at the mall on Friday, Robbiex11b and i showed up a little early and had lunch with
some family, received a couple of the classic "oh my word!!" looks, but nothing else. Later we met up with DanM and walked around the mall. I noticed a couple more of the "OMW" looks. I also noticed that the security guard that walked passed us did not notice our weapons until the second passing, but offered a friendly "hey guys".

I have heard some very negative stories involving 12 Oaks and Novi in the past but all my experiences have been pretty much the same in that area.

DanM and Steve Jaye it was very nice to meet you guys, and I would hope we will be able to do this again soon.

DinoX
 

DrTodd

Michigan Moderator
Joined
Jun 20, 2008
Messages
3,272
Location
Hudsonville , Michigan, USA
You're arguing specifics against generalities. I wrote that it seems that younger looking people tend to get hassled more. Not that younger looking people will get hassled more or that all younger looking people will get hassled or that only younger looking people will get hassled.

After reading these stories for a few years now it seems to me to trend toward younger folks get hassled more often.

Just because it hasn't happened to you doesn't negate everything I've read in the past.

Bronson


I've actually given this some thought over the last year, even going so far as compiling an historical list of incidents going back to the old archived posts. I then tried to pull out the factors involved. OK, really I read posts of reported incidents and kind of came across some general impressions and have coupled that with personal experience...
1. Look like a LEO, less problem.
2. Time of day is a factor
3. Alone or with a group; group appears less of a problem. Also, male with female and being part of a group with children lessens the chances.
4. Age is a factor.
5. Gender of carrier is a factor.
6 Type of establishment is a factor
7. What you carry is a factor. Type/Size
8 Clothing is a factor.
9 How one acts is a huge factor.
10. How cognizant of OC being legal people are.
12. Demographics of individuals observing you... this is a broad stroke here; it was intentional.

I'm sure many here could add a few more... my point being that there are many factors involved to some degree or another.
Bronson is correct in stating one (age) tends to have an effect, with younger individuals being confronted more than older ones. But "tends" is the operative word, and I'll repeat his point of general v specific.
Personally, I carried for over 3 years and was kicked out of the local Walmart when I was dressed in my work-casual dockers and polo-type shirt... while doing some shopping when the store was nearly empty. Clothing was definitely not the factor, rather it was most likely one of the others or some "factor x" that was present.
 
Last edited:
Top