Johnyt101
Regular Member
imported post
I believe legal action could produce a victory for freedom, so good luck! However, your argument about the privileges and immunities clause will go no where do to the slaughter house cases. Your best chance for making a difference would be to challenge the open carry ban (which you are) and Denver's ban on "AWs." On the open carry front, you could most likely win with a new CO Supreme Court ruling vindicating the fact that it violates preemption. Or in federal court, Scalia makes it very clear in Heller that open carry is a right reaffirmed in the Second Amendment. Also in Heller, the court ruled a ban on handguns was unconstituional. They did not specify what kind of hanguns (revolvers vs semi-autos), they struck down a ban on all handguns. So you could argue that since semi-autos are in common use and the Supreme Court struck down a ban on all handguns (including semiautos), a ban on semi-auto rilfes aka assault weapons is unconstitutional. How can semiauto handguns be constitutionally protected but not semiauto rifles?
I believe legal action could produce a victory for freedom, so good luck! However, your argument about the privileges and immunities clause will go no where do to the slaughter house cases. Your best chance for making a difference would be to challenge the open carry ban (which you are) and Denver's ban on "AWs." On the open carry front, you could most likely win with a new CO Supreme Court ruling vindicating the fact that it violates preemption. Or in federal court, Scalia makes it very clear in Heller that open carry is a right reaffirmed in the Second Amendment. Also in Heller, the court ruled a ban on handguns was unconstituional. They did not specify what kind of hanguns (revolvers vs semi-autos), they struck down a ban on all handguns. So you could argue that since semi-autos are in common use and the Supreme Court struck down a ban on all handguns (including semiautos), a ban on semi-auto rilfes aka assault weapons is unconstitutional. How can semiauto handguns be constitutionally protected but not semiauto rifles?