• We are now running on a new, and hopefully much-improved, server. In addition we are also on new forum software. Any move entails a lot of technical details and I suspect we will encounter a few issues as the new server goes live. Please be patient with us. It will be worth it! :) Please help by posting all issues here.
  • The forum will be down for about an hour this weekend for maintenance. I apologize for the inconvenience.
  • If you are having trouble seeing the forum then you may need to clear your browser's DNS cache. Click here for instructions on how to do that
  • Please review the Forum Rules frequently as we are constantly trying to improve the forum for our members and visitors.

common school policy about OC

MKEgal

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2010
Messages
4,385
Location
in front of my computer, WI
.



This was posted on the MOC FB page. Apparently this policy has been suggested to several schools / school boards in Michigan, so those of you who are the activist sort need to make sure yours isn't planning something stupid like this. And WHY is a county prosecutor having anything to do with school policy? There's nothing illegal about OC on school grounds, but there is about inciting panic (which is what this policy does to schools, staff, students, etc.) as well as wasting police resources.

This is the comment which was posted on FB:
These are "guidelines" that county prosecutors are proposing to school superintendents. This came from Tuscola County Prosecutor Mark Reene, although I can see that he simply copied it from OAISD which would be Ottawa County.




.
 

MKEgal

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2010
Messages
4,385
Location
in front of my computer, WI
Here's my analysis:

On pg 2, that "general guideline" #3 conflicts with #1.
Wouldn't surprise me if #2 conflicted with #1 also.
#5 - classroom visits arranged 2 days prior?? What are they trying to hide? What are teachers doing that they would change when they knew a parent would be present?
On all pages, remove the quotes around open carry. In some places it could be replaced with openly carried, but in general should just say pistol.

Page 3, #4, 5, & 7 - can only see your kid after police have checked you out, and only in a special area?!?! Again, why are they persecuting the good parents, and why treat them so differently from everyone else?
Why waste police time responding to a MWAG (which you _know_ is how they'll call it in) when the principal could look at it & see the expiration date? (Surely at least the principal would be smart enough to be able to figure out that the date on the card is before or after the current date.)

#6 might conflict with state law - is there anything in state law saying that pistols must remain in their holster, or that long guns are not allowed on school property?

#8 - why waste the time of police or the principal escorting a parent around the school, when they don't waste their time on any other parent... who might have a concealed gun, or a knife?

#10 sounds like they're going to notify every teacher & volunteer & parent in the school, and are refusing to extend equal protection to all visitors, based on their legal exercise of a civil right

Page 4, "shelter in place! call law enforcement!"
What a waste of resources, and they're scaring the kids too. :mad: Getting them used to being treated like criminals.
I'm curious to hear what the police chief thinks about this proposed plan, the waste of manpower.
 

Raggs

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2012
Messages
1,191
Location
Wild Wild West Michigan
I would think that the second the pistol came out of the holster most judges would be happy to convict you of brandishing. The other part of it is off topic in this forum as it pertains to long guns.
 

FreeInAZ

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
2,514
Location
Secret Bunker
This topic is very important IMHO. Why? Public schools not only in MI, across the entire USA continue to write & impose policies that are contrary to the law! If groups of freedom loving Americans stood up, organized and held organized, calm, demonstrations on the public sidewalks near schools, things would change quickly. The administration of these rogue school systems would be faced with a choice: close /lockdown schools every time one of these demonstrations occurred. Or simply acknowledge their policies are bunk and do nothing to protect anyone.

If the planners of these demonstrations was smart and did them in the morning just before school started; this would keep the kids from being in class. Why is this important? If enough students miss school, the school system loses federal & state money. No administration wants to admit it, but what really counts is money.


Now the objective would not be to punish kids & parents for stupid and immoral school policies. So organizers should make every effort at getting the message out in the press days prior to demonstrations and also use the media to explain that a legal activity should not be forbidden by irrational school policies. Done well, this could stop the nonsense in schools across the country.

This may never happen - but if it does I'll be joining the ranks of peaceful demonstrators, law-abiding citizens who want nothing more than a fighting chance to live. :eek: Also to make school less of a mass shooters wet dream, as they would then know a high probability of bullets coming their way would make their success less likely. These pukes want to die, however what they really want is to have their names in the media for years after their cowardly acts ...they won't get that if they can only kill one or two people before they are shot dead... end of school mass shootings...maybe.

Edit = add content/clarity
 
Last edited:

OneForAll

Regular Member
Joined
Mar 26, 2012
Messages
278
Location
Davison
This topic is very important IMHO. Why? Public schools not only in MI, across the entire USA continue to write & impose policies that are contrary to the law! If groups of freedom loving Americans stood up, organized and held organized, calm, demonstrations on the public sidewalks near schools, things would change quickly. The administration of these rogue school systems would be faced with a choice: close /lockdown schools every time one of these demonstrations occurred. Or simply acknowledge their policies are bunk and do nothing to protect anyone.

If the planners of these demonstrations thought smart and did them in the mornings just before school started; this would keep the kids from being in class. Why is this important? If enough students miss school, the school system loses federal & state money.

Now the objective would not be to punish kids & parents for stupid and immoral school policies. So organizers should make every effort at getting the message out in the press days prior to demonstrations and also use the media to explain that a legal activity should not be forbidden by irrational school policies. Done well, this could stop the nonsense in schools across the country.

This may never happen - but if it does I'll be joining the ranks of peaceful demonstrators, law-abiding citizens who want nothing more than a fighting chance to live. :eek:

Great post FreeInAZ, you deserve a pat on the back for a great idea! Fight fire with fire, if you want to lockdown our kids and prevent their education because of a lawful activity, then we will cause more lockdowns to prevent the kids from even entering the building to affect schools funding.
 

OC4me

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2009
Messages
758
Location
Northwest Kent County, Michigan
.
This was posted on the MOC FB page. Apparently this policy has been suggested to several schools / school boards in Michigan, so those of you who are the activist sort need to make sure yours isn't planning something stupid like this.
Anybody have a better link to that document? I couldn't open it. I hope it doesn't require logging because I don't do Facebook.
 

FreeInAZ

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
2,514
Location
Secret Bunker
I hear Oc4me... I don't either. IMHO it is a data mining / tracking/ surveillance - treasure for the government. Couple this with the "stupid/troll" factor of a growing # of users and I say ...no thanks.
 

OC4me

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2009
Messages
758
Location
Northwest Kent County, Michigan
I hear Oc4me... I don't either. IMHO it is a data mining / tracking/ surveillance - treasure for the government. Couple this with the "stupid/troll" factor of a growing # of users and I say ...no thanks.

;-) All the same, I'd really like to see that school document. Can anyone post or PM me a better link? I've got kids in the local school and I'd sure like to know what the heck this 'prosecutor' is sending out to our school administration.
 

MI_XD

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2010
Messages
90
Location
SW Michigan
OK, that link got it. Thanks.

From the flow chart... How can someone from the school request that you show them your CPL? That is something that is only required to show a LEO when they arrive/talk with you?
Most everything they have in that chart would be "restricting the transporting or carrying" as put out in 1102.

MI_XD
 

bigt8261

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2013
Messages
181
Location
Grand Rapids
A LEO would first need to suspect you of committing a crime before he can demand to see your CPL. At that point, an awkward situation might ensue when you tell him that you can't show him something you are not required to have on your person.
 

FreeInAZ

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
2,514
Location
Secret Bunker
A LEO would first need to suspect you of committing a crime before he can demand to see your CPL. At that point, an awkward situation might ensue when you tell him that you can't show him something you are not required to have on your person.

After reading the document - I can say with certainty, if there was a organized effort to conduct (before school) demonstrations of lawful OC done repeatedly. The schools would have no choice but to repeal this STUPID policy or face HUGE financial hardships do to loss of "attendance based" funding. On another note - most school functions are at best attended by auxiliary police officer(s). In most cases they have no more arrest powers than a citizen as they are NOT duly qualified/accredited. This means that if 50 OCers showed up for a baseball/basketball/ football/ etc... game before most others... the school would have to call for multiple officers...doing so could result in delays, or even cancellations of games. In most rural areas...this means 15 to 30+ minute response times and a call for mutual assistance from neighboring LE agencies.... over time and repeated wastes of manpower aka MONEY, I see local LE putting far less effort into sending a "surge" of PEACE officers to schools for lawful activities.

If anyone in MI was able to organize such a effort, I'm pretty sure they would be successful. :D
 
Last edited:
B

Bikenut

Guest
After reading the document - I can say with certainty, if there was a organized effort to conduct (before school) demonstrations of lawful OC done repeatedly. The schools would have no choice but to repeal this STUPID policy or face HUGE financial hardships do to loss of "attendance based" funding. On another note - most school functions are at best attended by auxiliary police officer(s). In most cases they have no more arrest powers than a citizen as they are NOT duly qualified/accredited. This means that if 50 OCers showed up for a baseball/basketball/ football/ etc... game before most others... the school would have to call for multiple officers...doing so could result in delays, or even cancellations of games. In most rural areas...this means 15 to 30+ minute response times and a call for mutual assistance from neighboring LE agencies.... over time and repeated wastes of manpower aka MONEY, I see local LE putting far less effort into sending a "surge" of PEACE officers to schools for lawful activities.

If anyone in MI was able to organize such a effort, I'm pretty sure they would be successful. :D
I think, my opinion, that having OC'ers get between the parents and a baseball, basketball, football game would be very unwise. Many folks have more of themselves invested in sports than they have in anything else which is apparent by the behavior of fans everywhere.

Holding schools accountable is one thing... getting in the way of a "game" for some fans is about as heinous an act as getting between them and a cold beer.
 

FreeInAZ

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
2,514
Location
Secret Bunker
I think, my opinion, that having OC'ers get between the parents and a baseball, basketball, football game would be very unwise. Many folks have more of themselves invested in sports than they have in anything else which is apparent by the behavior of fans everywhere.

Holding schools accountable is one thing... getting in the way of a "game" for some fans is about as heinous an act as getting between them and a cold beer.

I agree to some extent my friend. I was simply speaking to points in their memo. However if done correctly in stages, if the gloves needed to come off.. its an option. As stated before, use the media to give notice and make the schools explain why their bad policy is causing issues
 
Top